• Nikonreseñas
  • Nikonreview
  • Fotoschool
  • Ode to Ugliness
  • Portfolio
  • Contact
  • Log in

The new Nikon D800. Medium Format akin or not? A spec comparison with the Pentax 645D

by gerard.prins on Mar 1, 2012 in Nikon Cameras, NikoNews, Review
The new Nikon D800. Medium Format akin or not? A spec comparison with the Pentax 645D

59% Of voters on NikonRumors wanted a 16 Mp. camera. Well, good luck to them.
Loosely quoting the late Steve Jobs: if you ask consumers what they want, you'll never get any real work done...
As a consolation, the D700 will stay part of the Nikon line-up – at least for a while – according to a Nikon France executive, so all these disgruntled potential buyers can still get a full-frame Nikon without the "excessive" resolution of the D800, at an agreeable 20% discount.
The D700 sells now for $2.200, down from $2.700, only days ago.

Notwithstanding, in 15,4 Mp. in DX mode the D800 is pretty close to these people's dreams, offers Full HD 1920x1080 30p video and a mayor general work-over at only a slight premium over the late D700.
Without even mentioning the rather exciting option to up resolution by a whopping 70%.
My bet is that, after the grumbling has died down, more people than not will prefer the D800 over its predecessor and end up shooting at 36 Mp. no matter what they say today.
How about that for a free upgrade that's only a button push away?




For the remaining 40 percent of us, Nikon has clearly upped the ante. A 36 Mp. sensor puts the D800 right up there with the $10.000 plus mid-formats, while the D800E – without AA filter (OLPF) – ought to be even more competitive as far as sharpness goes.
The latter is more likely to produce moiré and false color in very specific situations, but for studio, fashion and architecture shooters it is most definitely a valid option, especially considering its modest price ($3.300) in comparison with its medium-format peers.

The new Nikon D800. Medium Format akin or not? A spec comparison with the Pentax 645D

The bottom end of the MF category starts at roughly $10.000 with the Pentax 645D. With the discontinuation of Mamiya’s ZD, the only remaining integrated MF camera – the Leica S-System – comes currently in at $23.000. Without lenses, of course.
Digital MF backs cost much more. For example, the Phase One IQ 180 (80 Mp.) would set you back in the order of $50.000, without... BODY!

Even though some might argue that medium-format is an entirely different ball game, it is good to keep in mind that none of the current digital MF cameras comply with the 66 or even 645 standards of the film days. For now, the Phase One IQ 160 digital back comes closest, with a sensor size of 53.9x40.4 mm plus a heart-stopping price-tag. About $40.000.

The Pentax 645D, Phase One P40+ and Mamiya DM40 sensors all measure 44x33 mm (± 40 Mp. @ 6 mµ), which is a far cry from the 6x4,5 cm (± 75 Mp.) that at least the Pentax’s model name suggests, let alone 6x6 (± 100 Mp.).
With a resolution of 7.360 px. on the horizontal, the D800 in fact slightly exceeds the Pentax’s 7.260, however, the latter still wins on the vertical with roughly 10% more resolution (5.440 vs. 4.912 px.), which explains why its total resolution is slightly higher than the Nikon (39,5 vs. 36,15 Mp.).

Nikon claims that this new CMOS sensor is up to par with the D700’s, which makes the 645D’s Kodak CCD look rather outdated, in spite of its larger pixel pitch of 6.1 mµ vs. the D800’s 4.9, at a virtually equal pixel density.
Even in the extremely unlikely case that the D800 were to be under par in comparison with the D700 as far as high ISO is concerned, with 6.400 standard ISO it still comfortably outscores the 645D’s extended 1.600 ISO by two full stops, without even considering the noise the Pentax’s old-fashioned sensor will most likely introduce at its maximum ISO setting.

However much I like the Pentax, DSLRs are in a different league. Weight, operability, automation, compatibility, performance, comodity and price are all elements to factor in at the moment to decide to invest in a camera system, and for the large mayority of users – including those craving MF performance – the D800(E) has a clear edge.
For example: even though Pentax 645, 66 and 67 lenses are far more affordable than the ones of their direct competitors, they are hard to come by, still rather limited in focal range and at least as or more expensive than their pro-level Nikkor peers, with exception of the super-tele Nikkors.

Nikon, on the other hand, offer lenses that are maybe not at the absolute top of the charts performance-wise, but do offer very respectable quality at a reasonable price.
A good example are the 50 and 85 mm Nikkors. Although the most demanding users will most likely shell out for the f/1.4 versions, the quality differences with their f/1.8 siblings are fairly marginal –  especially on FX – while the price differences substantial: $1.200 in the case of the 85mm f/1.4G vs. the f/1.8G or D, for example.

Still, the extreme resolution of the D800(E) presents challenges of its own, resulting – among others – in Nikon publishing a document with recommendations aimed at allowing users to take full advantage of the camera and not be disappointed with sub-par performance due to optically poor lenses or flawed camera management.
After all, there is only a limited number of users who have the pro-level knowledge and skills to manage a medium-format akin camera.
Even pros who come from flagship DSLR’s may need to cultivate some habitual MF but unusual DSLR habits to take full advantage of the extreme resolutions the D800/D800E are capable of.

Focusing for starters – the camera is very unforgiving in comparison with lower resolution models – but shake reduction and micro-vibration management as well.
What used to be sturdy supports for relatively lowres cameras in comparison, may now – al of a sudden – produce unsatisfying results, while lenses once considered outstanding may flagrantly expose their flaws with cameras that place such extreme demands on optics.
In an ideal world, one would want to mount MF lenses on the D800, however, the likelihood of Nikon making its own or – even less likely – third party mid-format lenses somehow compatible with this camera is null, even if it were technically feasible.

The following graph compares the D800 specs with the Pentax 645D’s. Depending on your application, some advantages of one or the other may be irrelevant but, overall, Nikon appears to present us – once again – with a paradigm shift worth pondering: a portable studio with certain MF-akin management demands or MF studio quality with operability and portability restrictions. Take your pick…

Here, the advantages from a DSLR user’s point of view are marked in red. A MF studio user’s priorities might be different – even though I doubt that...
The objective is to change the (IMVHO) rather limited perspective of potential D700 upgraders, and position this camera where I believe it ought to be: as a direct competitor for low-end Pentax, Phase One and Mamiya digital Mid-Formats at between 1/3 and 1/10th of their suggested retail price.
If pre-orders are any indication, it appears that Nikon are betting right...

See also:
DxOMark: Nikon D800E and D800 take the top slots in Sensor Ratings.
DPreview: Nikon D800 first impressions.
Nikon and Adobe add support for the D4, D800 and D800E.
Nikon Rumors: Nikon D800 issues.

 
Nikon D800 (E)
Pentax 645 D
Sensor type CMOS CCD
Optical Low Pass Filter Yes / No (E version) No
Sensor size 35.9x24 mm 44x33 mm
Resolution (WxH px) 7.360x4.912 7.260x5.440
MP (effective) 36.15 39.49
Resolution DX (WxH px) 4800x3200 N/A
MP DX (effective) 15.36 N/A
Pixel pitch (mµ) 4.9 6.1
Sensor cleaning Yes Yes
File formats RAW (14 bits), TIF, JPG RAW (14 bits), JPG, DNG
File sizes FX & DX: L, M, S, 1:2, 5:4 L
Sensitivity (standard) 100-6.400 ISO (Lo-1, Hi-1, Hi-2) 200-1.000 ISO
Sensitivity max. 25.600 (Hi-2) 1600 ISO
Sensitivity min. 50 ISO (Lo-1) 100 ISO
Shutter speeds 1/8000 - 30 s., bulb 1/4000 - 30 s., bulb
Built-in flash Yes (CLS + commander mode) N/A
Flash sync speed 1/250, High-Speed FP 1/125, high-speed-sync
Flash modes Front/Rear-curtain, anti red-eye, anti red-eye+slow, slow Normal, anti red-eye, anti red-eye+slow, slow
Exposure metering TTL with 91,000-pixel RGB sensor TTL, open-aperture, 77-segment
Metering Modes Multi-segment (Matrix), Center-weighted, Spot Multi-segment (Matrix), Center-weighted, Spot
Shooting modes P/S/A/M Sensitivity priority, S, A, S+A, Bulb, X-Speed
Shooting speed (JPG) 4 fps @ full resolution 13 fps @ full resolution
Shooting speed (RAW) 4 fps @ full resolution 1.1 fps @ full resolution
AF modes AF-A (auto), AF-F, AF-S, AF-C, Face Priority, M, wide & normal area AF-S, AF-C, M
AF points 9/21/51 + 3D-tracking 11
Output HDMI (uncompressed), USB 3.0, Headphones HDMI, USB 2.0
Input Stereo Microphone, GPS and other 10-pin accesories N/A
Movie mode (max) Full HD 1.920x1.080 / 30 fps N/A
Compatible lenses FX & DX: AF-S, AF-I, AF, AI, AI-S, AI-P 645AF2, 645AF, 645A, 67 System (with adapter)
Storage Compact Flash + SD / SDHC / SDHX (one slot each) SD / SDHC (2 slots)
Weight 900 g. (without battery) 1.480 g. (incl. battery, cards)
Price $ 3.000 / $ 3.300 (E version) $ 9.996


Top

Want to help?

I'm a freelancer!
If this article is useful to you, you might want to consider a small contribution. Thank you!

Tags: 2012 3d 645d 85 mm adobe af af-a af-c af-f af-i af-s affordable ai ai-p ai-s amsterdam articles battery built-in flash camera cmos color commander mode compact flash comparison compatibility d800 series digital discount dpreview dslr dx elements exposure false flash free full hd fx gps html iso jpg kodak leica mamiya mf microphone mid format movie new nikkor nikon olpf optics pentax phase one photography photokina php portable raw rear-curtain release resolution rumors software specs standard stereo microphone steve jobs still studio super-tele tele third party upgrade video
  • « Adobe ACR 6.7 RC (CS5 only) and Nikon updates add support for the D4, D800/800E. Nikon software now also x64 native.
  • January 2012. Nikon launches the D4. Time for a review of its product strategy. »

No feedback yet


Form is loading...

Comment feed for this post

Want to help?

I'm a freelancer!
If my work is useful to you, please consider a small contribution. Thank you!

Search

Translate


Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 17

Articles

  • Astro photography for beginners
  • Upgrade or deal-breaker? Seven reasons not to buy the Nikon D7500 and get a D7200 instead
  • Your telescope as a super-tele lens: methods, tools, pros & cons of eyepiece projection and prime focus astrophotography
  • DIY heavy duty woodshop Crayford-type focuser with building plans
  • Is my camera motorized or motor-less, compatible with NAI, AI, AI-S, AI-P, AF-D, AF-I, AF-S lenses and GPS or not? Answers.
  • The Nikon F-mount. Manual focus NAI, AI, AI-S, AI-P, Series E and auto-focus AF-D, AF-I, AF-S, D- and G-Type lenses. A compatibility inventory
  • Why DxO Mark's lens “tests” are utter nonsense
  • Got a new camera? Problems with Photoshop or Camera RAW? Check out Nikon Capture NX-D. FREE!
  • Autofocus reloaded. AF-S, AF-C, AF-A, AF-F. 11, 39 and 51 point AF systems. Dynamic area AF, focus areas and 3D
  • When and how to use fill-in flash, high speed sync and slow sync flash
  • Adobe adds support for the Nikon Df, D610, D5300, D4S, D3300 and D810 in ACR 8.x (CS6 and CC ONLY)
  • Compatibility chart for Nikon DSLR and Adobe Camera RAW & DNG Converter (Updated 2016-06-12)
  • 25-02-2014: Nikon launches the top-of-the-line 16.2 Mp. D4S
  • Cool Stuff V. Godox Witstro AD-180 & AD-360 portable bare-tube flashes
  • Good news for wildlife and sports shooters: Tamron launches the Di SP 150-600mm f/5-6.3 VC USD
  • The Quick & Dirty Focus Test
  • Back Focus, Front Focus or Spot-on? Do the Domino Test
  • October 17, 2013. Nikon replace the D5200 with the D5300
  • October 8, 2013. Nikon launches the D610 to replace the 13 month-old D600
  • Nikon's numbers are dropping. Why?
  • Geotagging test of the Nikon D7100 and the Promote GPS N-90
  • How the DNG Converter makes your RAW files compatible with any version of ACR
  • Some very useful tips for shooting Video with your DSLR
  • Nikon announces to have produced the 80 millionth Nikkor
  • Adobe surveys potential CC customers. Mostly address the right issues, except the single most essential.
  • Flickr make a mayor change to their interface. Just in time or just too late?
  • Adobe Creative Cloud or CC. Cash Cows for Creative Criminals
  • Adobe adds support for the D5200 in ACR 7.3 and D7100 in 7.4 (CS6 Only)
  • Promote GPS 10-pin CA10 to D90-type CA90 connector conversion.
  • The D5200: Nikon’s most unnecessary launch ever.
  • Nikon's Premium Pricing and Pixel Overkill: A New Dead End Street?
  • Adobe adds support for the Nikon D600 in ACR 7.2 (CS6 only).
  • Adobe adds support for the D3200 in ACR 7.1 (CS6 only). D600 not yet supported.
  • Nikon D600 vs. D800. For what it offers, the D600 should cost $500 less.
  • EN-EL15 battery recall
  • To Goog Almighty: how do I get my search traffic back?
  • Adobe publishes Camera RAW and DNG Converter 6.7 final releases. The last for CS5.
  • Nikon launches the long overdue AF-S 28 mm f/1.8G Nikkor
  • Nikon launches the D3200, the WU-1a wireless mobile adapter and the 28mm f/1.8G prime lens
  • Flickr is dead. Long live Facebook
  • XQD vs. Compact Flash on the Nikon D4. Which is the fastest?
  • Adobe ACR 6.7 RC (CS5 only) and Nikon updates add support for the D4, D800/800E. Nikon software now also x64 native.
  • The new Nikon D800. Medium Format akin or not? A spec comparison with the Pentax 645D
  • January 2012. Nikon launches the D4. Time for a review of its product strategy.
  • That's it for Nikon in 2011
  • October 5, 2011. A farewell to Steve Jobs.
  • September 21, 2011. Nikon launches Nikon One: 2 mirror-less cameras, 4 lenses, and a host of accessories.
  • August 24, 2011. Nikon may finally give us the launches we have been waiting for. (Edited) Well, I guess not.
  • Sigma discontinues the 100-300mm f/4. Time to call upon Nikon for an affordable 400 and 500 mm
  • EN-EL3 rechargeable battery recall (D50, D70, D70s, D100)
  • Nikon launches the D5100 and the ME-1 stereo microphone for digital SLR
  • Cool Stuff IV. The Strobies XS bracket: turn your hot-shoe flash into a studio flash.
  • New software releases from Nikon, Adobe and Apple
  • Mac OS X 10.6 Digital Camera RAW Compatibility Update. Support for the Nikon D7000 and CP7000, among others.
  • Cool stuff III. The Superclamp: don't leave home without one (or two)
  • Adobe launches Camera RAW (CS5 ONLY) and DNG converter 6.3 RC. Support for the Nikon D7000 and D3100, among others.
  • Missed the D7000 launch, but went to Amsterdam, played the tourist, met my grandson and “tested” the D7000, Pentax 645D at Photokina
  • Nikon launch their own on-line store in the US. Unfortunately, it's outrageously expensive.
  • Nikon & NASA. Almost 40 years together in space.
  • Cool Stuff II: lenta.ru. Probably the coolest portal on the planet, right now.
  • Cool Stuff I: GoPro HERO wearable, waterproof 1080p HD digital video and still “sports” camera
  • The rumors were not too far off: Nikon launch the D3100 with the 18-55 mm f/3.5-5.6G VR.
  • Nikon View: could it get any worse? A crash test review of View NX2.
  • The rumors are no longer rumors. Nikon launch their new Coolpixes S1100 Pj and S5100.
  • NEW! Nikon View NX 2 now available for download.
  • Adobe Labs publishes the Camera RAW ACR 6.2 release candidate (CS5 Only) and DNG Converter v.6.2.
  • It's that time of the year again. Rumors about new Nikon DSLR cameras: D3100 and D7000 (D95).
  • JPG vs. RAW, 8-bits vs. 16-bits, sRGB vs. wide-gamut RGB. Which to choose, when and why
  • Shot befittingly with a Nikon: my grandson
  • Nikon EN-EL3e false low-battery warning problem. Possible solutions.
  • Swamped in comment Spam
  • Geo-tagging Flickr images: the coolest game on (Google) Earth.
  • Adobe releases Camera RAW ACR 5.7, probably the last update for CS4.
  • The earthquake in Chile and the power of photography.
  • Nikon updates software. Now compatible with Apple Snow Leopard (OS 10.6.x) and Windows 7, Vista 32/64 bits.
  • I'm not the only one who thinks Adobe is Lazy...
  • Nikon introduce 7 new Coolpix cameras. Finally move their butt, um, sensor. Launch their first BSI-CMOS in the P100.
  • Can I use Nikkor AI and AI-S manual focus lenses on my Nikon DSLR? Yes, you can!
  • Nikon's greatest hits, 1999-2009
  • Adobe Camera RAW ACR 5.6 RC (CS4 only) now available for download. Support for the Nikon D3S, among others
  • Green pictures in Nikon View?
  • Nikon View NX does not work on Snow Leopard (OS 10.6)
  • 14-10-2009. Nikon launch the D3S with 12.800 standard ISO plus the DX 85mm f/3.5 micro-Nikkor
  • RIP: the Nikon D300, officially discontinued
  • Which is the best RAW converter: Camera RAW, Nikon View, Capture or Phase One Capture One?
  • Adobe Camera RAW 5.5 Release Candidate (Free, CS4 ONLY). Support for the Nikon D300S and D3000
  • New Nikon camera? Photoshop or Camera RAW Trouble? Check out Nikon View NX! (Updated)
  • 30-07-2009: Nikon Launch the D300s and D3000 cameras. Specs here.
  • Nikon service advisory for a power related problem with the D5000 (certain serial numbers only)
  • The rumors confirmed: launch date for the Nikon D300s and D3000.
  • A good laugh for our Dutch friends...
  • My Nikon wish list. Some of it I can afford, some not (yet).
  • D5000 & 18-55, 55-200 Outfit for the price of a D90 (Body alone)
  • In depth D5000 review on DPreview
  • Competition for the Nikon GP-1(a). Promote Systems GPS N-90 for the D90, D6x0, D7K and D5K series, the D3100 and D3200
  • Nikon D300, D90 & D80 EN-EL3e false low-battery warning problem.
  • Let's stick it to Adobe and Nikon! 3 Alternatives to upgrading RAW software every time you get a new camera
  • Plausible rumors about the specs of the new Nikon D300s and more...
  • Adobe Camera RAW 5.4 Release Candidate (CS4 ONLY). Support for the Nikon D5000 and other cameras.
  • Teaser Campaign for the D400? More rumors: D400, D750.
  • Nikon D300, out of stock or discounted in stores in the US, France and Sweden. D40 and D80 discontinued in Europe.
  • Adobe now officially WORSE than MS. Sell by NOT doing, rather than doing.
  • “Geotagging” with your Nikon. Review of the Promote GPS N-1
  • Review: Nikon D40 + AF-S DX 18-55 mm. f/3.5-5.6GII ED kit. Maybe the best Nikon ever?
  • My Nikon cameras, the ones to come and why.
  • Review: 18-200 mm. f/3.5-6.3D IF DC Sigma. You can't have it All.
  • Review: APO 100-300mm f/4D EX HSM Sigma. Sharpness on a Shoestring
  • Review: AT-X PRO 12-24mm f/4G DX Tokina. Big Bang for your Buck
  • Dictionary of (digital) photography terms and abbreviations

©2019 by Gerard Prins All content of this blog is copyrighted. Articles may be reproduced only when providing a byline and a link to the original article. Images may not be reproduced without previous, written permission of their author(s). • Contact • Help • multiple blogs • web hosts